Abstract

Return to sport (RTS) in elite team sports is often portrayed as a linear pathway to clearance. Progression from injury to sustained performance contribution is complex and non-linear, particularly following severe injuries such as anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Using the metaphor of ‘We're Going on a Bear Hunt’, this masterclass conceptualises return-to-performance (RTPe) as a journey through inevitable obstacles requiring coordinated, context-sensitive decision-making. Extending the RTS continuum, we emphasise the influence of early injury response, expectation setting, progressive loading strategies, and structured reintegration beyond return to competition. Evidence across elite team sports demonstrates that RTPe is injury-specific and highly variable: athletes may regain technical outputs yet still lack the capacity to tolerate and consistently reproduce performance under competitive demands. Isolated physical or technical metrics risk misrepresenting recovery if not interpreted within tactical, organisational, and psychological context. Importantly, RTPe may be perceived differently across stakeholders, each of whom may prioritise different outcomes and indicators of success. We propose that RTPe is a multidimensional, stakeholder-informed process integrating durability, role execution, confidence, and sustained availability. RTPe should therefore be understood not as a discrete milestone, but as a dynamic, context-dependent journey requiring adaptability, alignment, and an individualised lens to support sustainable performance outcomes.