Welcome to

Lancashire Online Knowledge

Image Credit Header image: Artwork by Professor Lubaina Himid, CBE. Photo: @Denise Swanson


Establishing consensus for Effective Talent Development Environments in Sport

Dugdale, James H., Owen, Robin, Reeves, Matthew orcid iconORCID: 0000-0002-3903-2910, Andrew, Matthew, Kelly, Adam L., Unnithan, Vish, Lascu, Alex, Roberts, Simon J. and Martindale, Russell J. J. (2026) Establishing consensus for Effective Talent Development Environments in Sport. Journal of Expertise, 9 (3). pp. 162-163. ISSN 2573-2773

Full text not available from this repository.

Official URL: https://www.journalofexpertise.org/articles/volume...

Abstract

Background
Despite talent development garnering great professional, financial, and research interest, it is still regarded as a highly heterogenous field, with limited consensus on optimal practice (Baker et al., 2024).

Aim
A modified e-Delphi approach (Hohmann et al., 2018) was used to establish consensus among an array of expert researchers and practitioners working within talent development. Specifically, principles related to the environment were evaluated, whereby coaches and stakeholders can influence the development of talent.

Methods
Data collection took place via 3 online survey rounds hosted on Qualtrics. A total of 31 experts agreed to participate in round 1 (M age = 49.16 years; M experience = 21.39 years; n female = 2; n academics = 19; n practitioners = 12; majority working in the west; mix of team and individual sports); in this round, experts were shown a total of 18 statements, developed by the research team, and were asked to rate their relevance and wording. Experts were also asked to suggest additional statements at the end of round 1, which were rated in terms of relevance and wording in round 2. In round 3, the relative importance of statements was assessed.

Results
In round 1, all 18 statements achieved consensus greater than or equal to 70% on relevance and wording metrics. Based on expert feedback, 4 additional statements were generated and assessed in round 2, where they too reached consensus greater than or equal to 70% on both metrics. In round 3, experts provided a ranking, in order of importance, for all 22 statements.

Conclusion
The present results provide a framework for optimal practice within applied talent development environments, derived from a combined academic and applied viewpoint. Organisations involved in talent development may wish to consider the statements developed within this e-Delphi to inform their practice. Additionally, future studies are encouraged to empirically test the principles identified by the present expert panel.


Repository Staff Only: item control page