Welcome to

Lancashire Online Knowledge

Image Credit Header image: Artwork by Professor Lubaina Himid, CBE. Photo: @Denise Swanson


Coaches’ Experiences of the (De)Selection Process in Academy Soccer

Oakes, Pat, Grecic, David orcid iconORCID: 0000-0003-1487-8327 and Reeves, Matthew (2026) Coaches’ Experiences of the (De)Selection Process in Academy Soccer. Journal of Expertise, 9 (3). pp. 195-196. ISSN 2573-2773

Full text not available from this repository.

Official URL: https://www.journalofexpertise.org/articles/volume...

Abstract

Background
The secretive nature of academy football (soccer) in England has restricted knowledge of talent identification processes (Larkin & Reeves, 2018). While research has been conducted into how coaches and scouts assess talent, there is little work exploring the wider context of talent identification in academy football and the influences on talent selection within it (Reeves et al., 2018). Previous research has revealed the functions and outcomes of (de)selection processes in academy soccer (Hill et al., 2020; Kite et al., 2023). Further research is required to better understand the factors which influence these processes.

Aims
This study aims to explore coaches’ knowledge, experiences, and beliefs on current practices in talent identification and (de)selection in academy soccer to access new perspectives and contribute to an improved understanding of the realities of talent identification practices. The study aims to provide greater context to the decisions taken by coaches in the (de)selection process (Roberts et al., 2021).

Methods
Data were generated from a study investigating current practices in talent identification and selection in English academies, learning from coaches' experiences in category 1, 2, and 3 academies from the Premier League and Football League. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with n = 12 professional football coaches working at EPPP academies with the aim of exploring their experiences of the TI process and the factors which influence (de)selection decisions beyond coaches’ evaluations of players’ talent.

Findings
Before reaching the academy environment, grassroots coaches, grassroots league organisers, and academy scouts all make pre-selection decisions, determining the pool from which academy coaches can identify suitable talents. Within the academy, coaches’ enactment of their beliefs and preferences influence (de)selection decisions. The influence of figures who hold power within the club leads to players being signed, retained, and released for political reasons. Upon graduating from the academy, players’ fortunes are highly dependent on the state of the first team squad’s performance and managerial situation. The knowledge that coaches possess varies at different levels of academy soccer, as does that of their colleagues, leading to compromised decisions on talent.

Conclusion
A disconnect exists between research and practice in talent identification in academy soccer environments. The constraints of knowledge, finances and structures in which coaches operate often prevents them from following a model of perceived best practice, with coaches regularly making compromises in performing the role. Developing practitioner knowledge across the talent identification process would improve the quality of decisions and allow coaches to maximise their resources. Improving the connection between scouting and coaching, developing a clear strategy based on the specific environment and requirements of the club, and prioritising talent identification resources to
align with the club's aims would also support greater quality and consistency of decisions. While the present study provides practical context to current understanding of talent identification and (de)selection in academy soccer, further research is needed to bridge the gap between research and practice.


Repository Staff Only: item control page